Addressing housing affordability challenges requires reforms to strengthen the supply response to rising demand. Policies to increase housing density, improve land use and planning, and boost productivity and lower costs in the construction sector are needed for a well-functioning housing market. Ensuring adequate supply and funding for social housing would ameliorate living conditions for the most vulnerable, and help combat homelessness.
The government has prioritised housing policies with the 2021 Housing for All Plan. In a context of strong demand due to population growth, past under-investment and constrained supply (Figure 3) have led to affordability and viability challenges. Recent policies have contributed to an increase in housing completions, but supply-demand mismatches persist. Ongoing policies to improve productivity in the construction sector and address labour shortages should be continued. It will also be important to improve the data framework and digitisation of planning processes to complement the new Planning and Development Act.
An accurate assessment of housing needs is crucial for policy design. The recent increase in annual housing targets from 33 000 to around 50 000 is welcome, but does not fully reflect total housing needs arising from the legacy of past under-investment. Some local authorities use the results of the tool, which translates national targets to local ones, as ceilings rather than as minima. This can lower supply, especially in some urban areas, as planning permissions do not always translate into home completions.
The temporary tax measures introduced in recent budgets to address near-term affordability challenges should be phased out. The re-introduction of mortgage interest relief and extension of tax reliefs and credits for landlords and tenants are not targeted and can be regressive.
Higher tax rates on residential dwellings and land can support tax neutrality, by reducing homeownership bias, while strengthening incentives to develop land and build. The residential zoned land tax, set to replace the 7% vacant site levy, is broader in scope and administratively less costly. However, the annual rate of 3% should be raised. Furthermore, despite recent reforms, local property taxes remain low.
More sustainable land development is key to increasing housing supply, while maximising the use of existing infrastructure and preventing urban sprawl. Existing national land-use data, which are scattered across various sources and lack standardisation, and the absence of a land-use classification system lower the effectiveness of planning processes. The planned development of land-use maps should be prioritised.
High construction costs can be a barrier to the cost-effective implementation of planned spending increases on housing, and delivery of compact urban growth. They also make it difficult to deliver housing units at sale or rental prices consistent with costs of production and household incomes. Regularly assessing the drivers of relatively high Irish construction costs, easing regulations with respect to size and specification of units and increasing adoption of standardisation should be prioritised.
High rents and low rental supply have increased the need for public support to households and to combat homelessness. Reducing the complexity of rental regulation and ensuring greater certainty for investors can help boost supply. The provision of social housing is expanding but has not kept up with needs. The system is characterised by increasing costs and dependence on housing allowances and the private sector rental market. The current social housing funding model should be reassessed to allow a switch of some social transfers to the construction of social or affordable housing to ensure the long-term financial sustainability of the system. A higher supply of social housing, combined with streamlined allocation processes, can also help combat homelessness, which has risen over recent years.